Success Stories from FDIC’s Youth Savings Pilot Participants
Enhancing collaborations among schools, nonprofit organizations and banks is the foundation of the FDIC’s efforts to help young people learn about savings. The FDIC Youth Savings Pilot program included 21 FDIC-insured financial institutions during the 2014-15 and 2015-16 school years to identify promising approaches to combining financial education with the opportunity for students to open safe, low-cost savings accounts. Here we report on what three of the participating banks told the FDIC about their successes during and after the pilot.
We start with First Bank of Highland Park (FBHP), a community bank in Highland Park, Illinois. During the 2016-2017 school year, FBHP is piloting a new Individual Development Account (IDA) program for high school seniors that includes a financial education component. (IDAs are matched savings accounts that enable low-income families to save money for a financial goal such as buying a home, paying for post-secondary education, or starting or expanding a small business.) The eligible high school students apply to participate in the IDA program, complete the IDA agreement, set up a savings account and make monthly deposits. The students also attend two financial education classes focused on saving and budgeting taught by bankers using the Money Smart curriculum. The bank also provides the students with monthly newsletters containing tips for saving and budgeting for college. And, the bank matches each student’s savings up to $500 at the end of the program, with all funds going toward college expenses.
This new initiative is a partnership with College Bound Opportunities (CBO) in Highland Park, an organization that helps high-achieving, but low-income students on the North Shore of Chicago get into college and then graduate. “The students are excited to save money of their own and brag to one another about how much they've been adding to their savings account,” said Mari Najera, director of college access at CBO. “It helps motivate the other kids, builds a sense of accountability … and helps build a positive relationship between students and the bank.”
FBHP staff provided a financial education to approximately 200 students every school year through the new IDA program and Junior Banking Ambassador classes. Denise Bryant, director of marketing at First Bank of Highland Park, shared with Money Smart News that one of their keys to success is being flexible when teaching financial education in schools, as some teachers may make opportunities available with limited advance notice. Having the materials needed for a classroom session ready to go can be helpful. Also, she suggests confirming how much time you will have to speak as it can vary considerably.
Bryant also recommended identifying an individual, such as the principal, who can serve as the financial education “champion” and help the banker make connections with the teachers and other faculty. The “champion” may also be able to help identify opportunities to incorporate Money Smart into STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering and Math) lessons.
Athol Savings Bank, based in Athol, Massachusetts, has offered a Save$um Banking & Schools (Save$um) program in several local elementary schools for more than a decade. The students can open passbook savings accounts and make deposits during the weekly banking day in the cafeteria or other common areas of the school, with the help of student-tellers. The program is designed to educate children on the importance of saving money, being disciplined, and knowing the self-satisfaction of watching their money grow.
At the beginning of each school year, the bank sends a packet home with each child describing the program and includes a teller application and parental permission slip. Students who want to volunteer as tellers complete an application and are interviewed by bank and school staff. The only requirement from the bank for student-tellers is that they have basic math ability. Each school bank is operated by six to eight student-tellers. “We continue to use student-tellers along with parents and other volunteers to help oversee the programs,” said Kim Drudi, community banking officer at Athol Savings Bank.
Jodi Kirby, a teacher at Baldwinville Elementary School in Baldwinville, Massachusetts, said that through the Save$um Banking program, “We are able to provide the foundation of financial responsibility at a young age so when the students become productive citizens within the community they will be prepared to make adequate financial decisions.”
John Graziano, a former principal at Baldwinville Elementary School, added: “Providing real-life experiences for students enhances their learning at so many levels. For many years, students in the Narragansett Regional School District of Templeton, Massachusetts, have nurtured savings accounts and gained life-long experience and lessons, especially as bank tellers.”
Smiles from Save$um student-tellers at Phillipston Elementary School in Phillipston, Massachusetts
One of the student-tellers in an elementary school, Elizabeth Adams, previously said, “In my banking experience as a teller, I loved working with my friends and bank employees, and my dad was a volunteer in the program.” She added that the first week she and her fellow student-tellers didn’t know what to do, but by the last week they were more comfortable.
Commercial Bank in Harrogate, Tennessee, partnered with Kentucky’s Harlan County public school system to provide financial education to students in Grades 3-5 throughout the 2015-16 school year in all eight elementary schools. The training was tied to the bank’s Smart Cents, a financial literacy program geared to educating students in Pre-K through Grade 8. The teachers pick the lessons from Money Smart and the bankers lead the classes. The topics covered include managing money, setting financial goals, ways to invest and donate, and planning and preparing for the future. Bank employees logged 305 hours in the classrooms during the 2015-2016 school year. “With about 15 minutes of prep time, a banker can be ready to go into the classroom and teach a class,” said Michelle Huddleston, executive vice president, chief operating officer and compliance officer at Commercial Bank. “We love the Money Smart lessons and the ease of use.”
In addition, the Smarts Cents program provides students with hands-on experience in opening savings accounts at their school. Each school has a designated area for the deposit-taking activities, such as in the library, cafeteria or other location where there is plenty of student traffic. Teachers direct each class to the area so that students can make their deposits with a representative of Commercial Bank. The students can open the account with as little as $1, earn interest and receive statements in the mail.
The Smart Cents program also has support in the community. Several businesses, including local restaurants, have partnered with Commercial to offer the students incentives for saving. For example, the bank may give a student opening a new savings account a token for a free pizza at a local restaurant.
Huddleston said, “In my 25 years in banking, [the Youth Savings Pilot] has been, by far, the most rewarding experience that I’ve had both personally and professionally.”
Michelle Huddleston shown teaching Money Smart to students