
|
Managing the Crisis: The FDIC and RTC
Experience
Chronological Overview: Chapter Eighteen—1995
Chairman Ricki Helfer stated in the 1995 Annual Report, “For three generations
of Americans, federal deposit insurance – with the full faith and credit
backing of the U.S. government – has provided a reason for unconditional
faith in the banking system. It is a certainty in an uncertain world. The FDIC
will continue to make sure that faith in the banking system is justified.”
Table 18-1
|
1994 - 1995: FDIC at a Glance ($ in Millions) |
| |
12/31/94 |
12/31/95 |
Percent Change |
| Number of Bank
Failures |
13 |
6 |
-53.85% |
| Total Assets
of Failed and Assisted Banks |
$1,463.9 |
$802.1 |
-45.21% |
| Estimated Losses
on Failed and Assisted Banks* |
$179.0 |
$84.5 |
-52.79% |
Estimated Losses
as a Percent of Total Assets |
12.23% |
10.53% |
-13.90% |
| Assets
in Liquidation |
$16,737.9 |
$10,308.2 |
-38.41% |
| FDIC Staffing |
11,627 |
9,789 |
-15.81% |
| Number of Problem
Financial Institutions# |
264 |
193 |
-26.89% |
| Bank Insurance
Fund Balance |
$21,847.8 |
$25,453.7 |
16.50% |
| Bank Insurance
Fund Balance as a Percent of Insured Deposits |
1.15% |
1.30% |
13.04% |
| Savings Insurance
Fund Balance |
$1,936.7 |
$3,357.8 |
73.38% |
| Savings Insurance
Fund Balance as a Percent of Insured Deposits |
0.28% |
0.47% |
67.86% |
*Losses
for all resolutions occurring in this calendar year have been updated
through 12/31/03. The loss amounts on open receiverships are routinely
adjusted with updated information from new appraisals and asset sales,
which ultimately affect projected recoveries.
# This line item, starting in 1995, includes bank and savings associations.
Back
to table
Source:
FDIC, 1995 Annual Report and Reports from FDIC Division of Finance
and FDIC Division of Research and Statistics. |
Notable Events
-
In February, the FDIC unveiled its World Wide Web
page on the Internet, providing the public with ready
access to FDIC consumer information, press releases,
and statistics on banking.
- On April
1, the FDIC began a system to invoice and collect deposit
insurance premiums electronically. The new arrangement
will make the
process of calculating and collecting insurance assessments
more efficient and less burdensome. With the new method,
the FDIC experienced an error rate of less than 0.1 percent,
a
significant improvement over the error rate of 8 to 13
percent under the previous manual, paper-based system.
The new process
further proved its value in September 1995, when the
FDIC used it to refund $1.5 billion to BIF-insured institutions
within
10 days of a recapitalization announcement.
- On Apri1 24, for
the first time in the agency’s 61-year history, the Board approved
a corporate-wide strategic plan. Major goals centered
on identifying and addressing risks to the insurance
funds and improving communications
with the public.
- On May 17, the
FDIC announced a reorganization that included the creation
of four new divisions: the Division of Insurance (DOI)
to identify risks to the
insurance funds; the Office of the Ombudsman (OO) to
respond to questions or concerns about the FDIC; the
Division of Administration (DOA) which
consolidated the three separate offices of personnel
management, corporate services, and staff training; and
the Office of Policy Development (PD)
to coordinate policy development among all FDIC Divisions
and Offices, to evaluate the policy implication of regulatory
and legislative proposals,
and to quickly update corporate positions on emerging
issues.
- On July 28, the
last two FDIC-insured bank closings of 1995 occurred, bringing
the total for the year to six, which was the lowest number
since 1977.
- On August 8, the
FDIC Board voted to reduce premiums paid by institutions insured
by the Bank Insurance Fund in recognition of the health of
the banking industry and the increased strength of the fund.
The Board did not reduce
assessment rates for the Savings Association Insurance Fund
(SAIF), which remained seriously undercapitalized.
- On November 2,
the FDIC, the Federal Reserve Board, and the New York State
Banking Department issued joint cease-and-desist orders against
The Daiwa Bank,
Limited, Osaka, Japan and its insured New York subsidiary,
Daiwa Bank Trust Company. In September, Daiwa disclosed approximately
$1.1 billion
in securities trading losses at its New York City branch after
having concealed those losses from bank regulators.
- On November 9,
the FDIC announced a program to reduce staffing levels by offering
many career employees incentives to retire or to voluntarily
seek other employment.
- On November 14,
the FDIC reduced insurance premiums for a second time for BIF-insured
institutions. The rates for the seriously undercapitalized
SAIF fund were not reduced.
- On December 22,
Mississippi Banking Commissioner Joseph H. Neely was confirmed
by the U. S. Senate to be a member of the FDIC Board of Directors.
He was sworn
in on January 29, 1996. This marked the first time since August
1992 that all five Board positions were filled.
- On December 31,
the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC), created in 1989 to
manage and sell failed savings associations, officially closed.
All remaining assets
and liabilities were transferred to the FDIC-managed FSLIC
Resolution Fund (FRF). The FRF was established by law in 1989
to assume the assets
and obligations of the former FSLIC thrifts that failed prior
to January 1, 1989.
Economic/Banking Conditions
The U.S. economy
grew by an impressive 4.9 percent during 1995, as measured by GDP. Even so,
unemployment rose slightly from 5.5 percent to 5.6 percent. However, this
slight rise reflects a sharp increase in the number of persons seeking employment.
The number of employed persons rose by roughly 360,000, or 2.9 percent, to
125,088,000. New home sales were virtually unchanged from the 1994 level
of 670,000, down to 667,000. By contrast, the number of new housing starts
fell by 103,000 or 7.1 percent during the period.18-1
Inflation was meager at 2.5 percent, and the interest rate environment
was mixed. The discount rate rose 50 basis points from 4.75 percent to
5.25 percent, while 30-year mortgage rates fell by 202 basis points from
9.53 percent to 7.51 percent. Because new housing starts during the previous
year totaled more than twice the number of new homes sold, home builders
backed off in new starts from the 1994 level. While home builders paused
a briefly to allow demand to catch up to supply, office space demand actually
increased, producing a 140 basis-point drop in the vacancy rate from 15
percent to 13.6 percent.
Commercial banks experienced continued increases in profitability and
asset growth. Net income increased almost 10 percent to $49 billion. Loan
quality was also good, and delinquency and charge-off rates remained low
in all areas except consumer and credit card loans.
Commercial bank assets increased by 8 percent. Equity capital also grew
$37.5 billion or 12 percent. Non-interest income increased by $6.2 billion,
or 10.6 percent, reflecting strong growth in fee income. Non-interest expense
increased only 4.5 percent. This can be attributed to the improvement in
operating efficiency which was largely due to decreases in employee costs
and occupancy costs relative to total revenue.
Commercial and Industrial loans experienced their largest increase in
the last 15 years. In addition, commercial real estate loans increased
by 5.75 percent. Consumer loans and consumer debt also increased. The increase
in both of these areas is related to the rise in credit card use. Credit
cards were becoming more accepted by consumers in ‘nontraditional’ places,
such as the grocery store.
Banks depended on managed liabilities as a source to fund asset growth.
Previously, banks used borrowings from abroad. However, because of the
decrease in deposit insurance premiums, banks were able to use large time
deposits as source of funds for the first time. Core deposits became significant
source of funds, which had previously been declining last year. Savings
accounts rose due to the establishment of ‘sweep accounts.’ 18-2
At end of 1995, there were 12,009 financial institutions in the United
States and 193 institutions18-3 on the problem bank list.18-4 Table 18-2
shows the number and total assets of FDIC insured institutions, as well
as their profitability as of the end of 1995.
|
Table 18-2
Open
Financial Institutions Insured by FDIC ($ in Billions)
| |
1994 |
1995 |
Percent Change |
| Number |
10,760 |
10,243 |
-4.80% |
| Total Assets |
$4,248.3 |
$4,577.9 |
7.76% |
| Return on Assets |
1.14% |
1.15% |
0.88% |
| Return on Equity |
14.43% |
14.32% |
-0.76% |
| |
1994 |
1995 |
Percent Change |
| Number
|
1,843 |
1,727 |
-6.29% |
| Total Assets |
$770.8 |
$760.5 |
-1.34% |
| Return on Assets |
0.56% |
0.76% |
35.71% |
| Return on Equity |
7.16% |
9.47% |
32.26% |
| US Branches of
Foreign Banks |
51 |
39 |
-23.53% |
Source: FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile, Fourth Quarter 2001.
| Bank
Failures
During 1995, the FDIC resolved six FDIC-insured
institutions, and the failed institutions had combined assets
of approximately $802.1 million. The size of the bank failures
in 1995 was the lowest since 1980 when failed bank assets totaled
$239.3 million, and the number of failures was the lowest since
1977 when there were also only six failures.
A recent estimate of losses per transaction type is shown in
Table 18-3.
Table 18-3
|
1995
Estimated Losses by FDIC Transaction Type ($ in Millions) |
Transaction
Type |
Number
of
Transactions |
Total
Assets |
Estimated
Loss*
as of 12/31/03 |
Estimated
Losses as a
Percent of Assets
|
| P&As |
6 |
$802.1 |
$84.5 |
10.53% |
*Losses
for all resolutions occurring in this calendar year have been updated
through 12/31/03. The loss amounts on open receiverships are routinely
adjusted with
updated information from new appraisals and asset sales, which ultimately
affect projected recoveries.
Back
to table
Source: Reports from FDIC Website – Historical Statistics on Banking.
Payments to Depositors
and Other Creditors
In the six financial
institutions that failed in 1995, deposits totaled $776.4 million in 47,651
deposit accounts. Dividends paid on all active receiverships totaled over
$3.9 billion in 1995.
There have been a total of 2,127 18-5 insured financial institution resolutions
since the FDIC began operations in 1934. Of this total, 1,445 were P&A
transactions, 79 were open bank assistance transactions, and 603 were deposit
payoff transactions.
Total disbursements by the FDIC since January 1, 1934, have amounted to
$104.3 billion. Of that amount, actual and projected recoveries are anticipated
to be approximately $67.4 billion, which equates to a projected loss of
$36.9 billion to the BIF fund.
Asset Disposition
At the beginning of 1995, the FDIC held $16.7 billion in assets from
failed institutions, and acquired some $550 million in assets from the
six financial institutions that failed during the year. The FDIC successfully
collected, sold, or otherwise resolved 40 percent, or almost $7 billion,
of its asset inventory during the year. This included 2,687 real estate
properties which were sold for $573.3 million, representing 94.3 percent
of their appraised value. Also included were over 23,750 loans and other
assets totaling $2 billion that were sold in sealed-bid and other asset
marketing events, resulting in sales proceeds of 97.7 percent of the appraised
value of these assets. At year-end 1995, the FDIC held $10.3 billion in
assets for liquidation. That included $8.8 billion in BIF assets, $6 million
in SAIF assets, and $1.5 billion in FRF assets.
The congressional appropriation for affordable housing was reduced from
$15 million to $3.7 million during the year. Notwithstanding this reduction,
the FDIC was able to help qualified buyers purchase 412 single-family properties
during the year. In addition, eight multifamily properties containing 225
units were sold to nonprofit organizations and public agencies.
Other financial recoveries during the year included $252 million from professional
liability settlements or judgments, and $7.6 million in collections from
court-ordered restitution from individuals convicted of bank fraud. Table
18-4 shows the FDIC’s assets in liquidation and Chart 18-1 shows the
asset mix.
|
Table 18-4
|
1995
FDIC End of the Year Assets in Liquidation ($ in Billions*) |
| Asset
Type |
12/31/94
Book
Value |
1995
Assets
Acquired |
1995
Prin.
Coll. |
1995
Write
Downs |
12/31/95
Book
Value |
12/31/95
Est. Rec.
Value |
Commercial Loans
|
$4.5 |
0.3 |
-0.2 |
2.0 |
$2.6 |
|
| Mortgage Loans |
6.4 |
0.2 |
0.5 |
3.2 |
4.0 |
|
| Other Loans |
0.2 |
0.0 |
0.0 |
0.1 |
0.0 |
|
| Real Estate Owned |
1.1 |
0.1 |
0.2 |
0.8 |
0.7 |
|
| Judgments |
1.7 |
0.0 |
0.5 |
0.8 |
1.5 |
|
| Securities |
0.2 |
0.0 |
-0.1 |
-0.1 |
0.0 |
|
| Other Assets |
1.3 |
0.0 |
0.2 |
0.7 |
0.7 |
|
| Equity in Subs. |
0.2 |
0.0 |
0.0 |
0.1 |
0.1 |
|
| Deficiencies |
1.1 |
0.0 |
0.3 |
0.7 |
0.7 |
|
| Totals |
$16.7 |
$0.6 |
$1.4 |
$8.3 |
$10.3 |
|
*Totals
may not foot due to rounding differences.
Back
to table
Source: Reports from FDIC Division of Finance.
Chart
18-1
1995
FDIC End of Year Asset Mix
d
|
Chart
18-2
FDIC/RTC Staffing
|
|
d |
Insurance
Fund and Staffing With the continuing recovery of the banking industry and institution’s
earnings at record levels, 1995 was another positive year for the BIF. The
BIF grew to a record high of $25.5 billion at the close of 1995, which represented
a 16.5 percent increase from the year-end 1994 balance of $21.8 billion. The
BIF was in the strongest position it had experienced since 1971, which was
the last time the bank deposit insurance fund exceeded 1.25 percent of insured
deposits. The SAIF grew to a balance of $3.4 billion at year-end, which represented
a 73.4 percent increase over year-end 1994.
In May, Chairman Helfer announced significant organizational changes
|
including the creation of a Division of Insurance, an Office of the Ombudsman,
a Division of Administration, and an Office of Policy Development. The Division
of Administration consolidated the functions of three separate offices for
personnel management, corporate services, and staff training.
In November, senior management announced a two-phased buyout program for
career FDIC and RTC employees with incentives either to retire or voluntarily
resign. Employees in the first phase were eligible to leave by year-end,
and more than 300 accepted. Employees in the second phase began leaving during
the first quarter of 1996 through the third quarter of 1997. For both phases,
940 employees accepted the buyout offer.
The RTC staffing totals include employees who were organizationally transferred
from the RTC to the FDIC in Spring/Summer 1995 but who continued to work
exclusively on RTC functions throughout 1995. The RTC totals also include
certain FDIC employees in Chicago who were dedicated to RTC functions early
in 1995, and who worked exclusively on these RTC functions for the balance
of 1995.
At year-end, the FDIC had 9,789 employees (RTC employees totaled 2,067),
down approximately 16 percent from year-end 1994 and 37 percent below the
peak level in the second quarter of 1993. These figures reflect the continuing
decline in agency workload from bank failures. Total staffing including the
RTC employees equaled 11,856. Chart 18-2 shows the staffing levels for the
past five years.
|
|
Table 18-5
Resolution
Trust Corporation
|
1994 - 1995: RTC at a Glance ($ in Millions) |
| |
12/31/94 |
12/31/95 |
Percent Change |
| Number of Conservatorships
at the beginning of the year |
63 |
1 |
-98.41% |
| Number of Conservatorships
added during the year |
0 |
0 |
0.00% |
| Thrifts in the
ARP Program* |
2 |
2 |
0.00% |
| Total of all
thrift takeovers |
2 |
2 |
0.00% |
| Conservatorships
resolved during the year |
62 |
1 |
-98.39% |
| Thrifts in the
ARP Program* |
2 |
2 |
0.00% |
| Total of thrift
resolutions |
64 |
3 |
-95.31% |
| Conservatorships
at the end of the year |
1 |
0 |
-100.00% |
| |
12/31/94 |
12/31/95 |
Percent Change |
| Conservatorships |
$0 |
$0 |
0.00% |
| Thrifts in the
ARP Program |
$129 |
$426 |
230.23% |
| Total |
$ 129 |
$426 |
230.23% |
| Estimated Losses
on thrift resolutions** |
$15 |
$63 |
320.00% |
| Estimated Losses
as a Percent of Total Assets |
11.93% |
14.79% |
23.97% |
| |
12/31/94 |
12/31/95 |
Percent Change |
| Conservatorships |
$2,067 |
$0 |
-100.00% |
| Receiverships |
$22,900 |
$7,689 |
-66.42% |
| Total |
$24,967 |
$7,689 |
-69.20% |
| RTC Staffing |
5,899 |
2,067 |
-64.96% |
*Thrifts
placed into the ARP program are included for clarity, although they were
never placed into the conservatorship program. Back
to table
**Losses
for all resolutions occurring in this calendar year have been updated through
12/31/95. The loss amounts are routinely adjusted with updated information from
new appraisals and asset sales, which ultimately affect projected recoveries. Back
to table
Source: RTC August 1989/September 1995 Statistical Abstract (Amended April
1996) and Reports from FDIC Division of Research and Statistics.
Notable Events
The
RTC ceased operations on December 31, 1995, and transferred all employees,
remaining assets, liabilities, and responsibilities to the FDIC. During its
lifetime, the RTC resolved 747 thrift institutions, including 706 conservatorships.
Since its inception through December 31, 1995, the RTC had disposed of assets
with a book value of $455 billion, or nearly 98 percent of the approximately
$465 billion (book value) in assets for which it had been responsible.
S&L Resolutions
In
1995, the RTC resolved three thrifts. At the start of 1995, one thrift
with total assets of $2.1 billion was in the RTC’s conservatorship
program. No new thrifts entered the program during 1995; and the one
remaining thrift was subsequently resolved, leaving no thrifts in the
conservatorship program at the end of 1995.
In 1995, all three thrift resolutions were purchase and assumption
(P&A) transactions, and all deposits were transferred to the acquirers.
The three thrifts had total assets of $1.7 billion.
Table 18-6 shows conservatorships and receiverships at year-end 1995.
|
Table 18-6
|
Item |
Total |
| In
Conservatorship at 12/31/94 |
1 |
| Conservatorships
added in 1995 |
0 |
| Subtotal |
1 |
| Conservatorships
resolved in 1995 (New Receiverships) |
1 |
| Conservatorships
remaining 12/31/95 |
0 |
|
Item |
Total |
| Receiverships
as of 12/31/94 |
744 |
| New Receiverships
that were previously Conservatorships in 1995 |
2 |
| New Receiverships
that were resolved through ARP in 1995 |
1 |
| Total New Receiverships
during 1995 |
3 |
| Total Receiverships
as of 12/31/95 |
747 |
Source: RTC August 1989/September 1995 Statistical Abstract (Amended April
1996).
Payments to
Depositors and Other Creditors
In 1995, there were three resolutions
with total deposits of $1.8 billion in 227,980 deposit accounts.
Of the 747 insured thrift failures since the RTC began operations
in August of 1989, 497 were P&A transactions, 92 were payoff
transactions, and 158 were insured deposit transfers.
Asset Disposition
At
the beginning of 1995, the RTC held $25 billion in assets from
savings and loan associations in receivership and conservatorship.
Assets acquired during the year through conservatorships, other
resolved institutions, and putbacks or repurchases totaled $1.2
billion for the year. Losses and collections totaled $18.5 billion
for the year. At the end of 1995, the RTC’s remaining
inventory of assets in liquidation totaled $7.7 billion. Table
18-7 shows the RTC’s assets in liquidation and Chart 18-3
shows the asset mix.
|
Table 18-7
|
1995 RTC End of the Year Assets in Liquidation ($
in Billions*) |
| Asset
Type |
12/31/94
Total
Book
Value |
Assets
Acq’D
During The Yr.
|
1995
Collec-tions |
1995
Losses |
12/31/95
Total
Book
Value |
Memo Item |
1-4 Family
Mtges |
$4.8 |
$0.2 |
$2.9 |
$1.6 |
$0.5 |
$0.7 |
| Other Mtges |
6.5 |
0.4 |
3.5 |
2.0 |
1.4 |
0.1 |
| Other Loans |
2.2 |
0.0 |
1.1 |
0.6 |
0.5 |
0.0 |
| R/Estate Owned |
2.1 |
0.0 |
0.9 |
0.4 |
0.8 |
0.0 |
| Other Assets |
6.0 |
0.0 |
1.3 |
1.5 |
3.2 |
0.0 |
| Cash/Securities |
3.4 |
0.6 |
3.2 |
-0.5 |
1.3 |
0.5 |
| Totals |
$25.0 |
$1.2 |
$12.9 |
$5.6 |
$7.7 |
$1.3 |
Memo ITEM: : Assets transferred from conservatorship to receivership.
Does not affect total of assets in liquidation.
*Totals
may not foot due to rounding differences.
Back
to table
Source: RTC August 1989/September 1995 Statistical Abstract.
Chart
18-3
1995
RTC End of Year Asset Mix
Staffing
As previously
discussed, the FDIC accepted 132 available permanent RTC employees as FDIC
vacancies occurred during 1994. Total RTC staff at the end of 1994 was
5,899, which was down from 6,778 at the end of 1993.
|
|
18-1:
Bureau of Labor and Statistics, Department of Labor; Bureau of Economic
Analysis, Department of Commerce; Housing Market Statistics, National Association
of Home Builders; and Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation. Back
to Text
18-2:
Federal Reserve Bulletin Volume 82, Number 6, June 1996. Back
to Text
18-3:
Starting in 1995, the figure for problem institutions includes both commercial
and savings institutions. Back
to Text
18-4:
FDIC Quarterly Banking Profile, Fourth Quarter 1995. Back
to Text
18-5:
In 1988 there were 21 assistance agreements that resolved 79 institutions.
The FDIC annual report (source data) calculates failure data per transaction;
this report calculates failures per failed institution. Actual resolutions
through 1995 totaled 2,185. Back
to Text
|