|
Home > Industry Analysis > Research & Analysis > National Regional Outlook, First Quarter 2001 |
|||
|
National Regional Outlook, First Quarter 2001 |
||
Three Industries Navigating in a Competitively Charged EnvironmentThe rising tide of a booming economy in the United States has lifted the boats of a broad spectrum of industries over the past nine years. Some industries, however, have fallen on hard times despite continued economic expansion. These industries represent a broad cross-section of the economy. Problems in these industries were precipitated by diverse factors, reflecting the differences among sectors in industries ranging from old economy (such as textiles) to services (such as health care) to those on the horizon (such as telecommunications). These industries will navigate in turbulent waters over the next few years. All three face an uncertain economic outlook, changing public policies that can influence their operating environment, and fierce competition. The importance of these industries to the U.S. economy varies based on employment. The telecommunications industry accounts for about 1.4 million jobs, or 0.85 percent of total U.S. employment.1 Health care, on the other hand, contributes over 11 million jobs, or 7 percent of total employment. Textile industry employment has been falling steadily for many years and is now under 550,000, accounting for less than 0.40 percent of total U.S. employment. 1 Source: Economy.com. Includes employment in telecommunications services, telecommunications equipment manufacturing, and cable television. As diverse as these industries are, a common denominator exists. Intense competition characterizes their operating environment, leaving little room for strategic missteps. Indeed, there have been reports that these industries have been significant contributors to the recent rise in problem bank loans. With a better grasp of the origins of stress in these industries comes a basis for understanding the lending risks associated with a changing policy and economic environment in the years to come. The following discussion describes trends and developments contributing to stress in these industries and looks at the near- and long-term outlook. Our discussion also looks at the implications for the insured institutions lending to the telecommunications, health care, and textiles industries. TelecommunicationsThe telecommunications sector consists of several industry subsectors, including telecommunications services, cable television, and telecommunications equipment, all of which are facing significant challenges. Telecommunications Services Rapid growth in the telecommunications services industry has been fueled by strong domestic consumer demand. However, the pace of consumption of telecommunications services has slowed in recent months. This sector has experienced booming growth in revenues from computer network access since 1998, while local and long distance revenues have grown at a much more moderate pace (see Chart 1). Chart 1 |
|
Rapid change and intense competition characterize the industry environment. Long distance businesses, in particular, have experienced fierce competition, resulting in severe pricing pressures. Competitors include both established and new wireline long distance providers, as well as wireless services. Local telephone companies, however, have fared well in recent years, as residences and small businesses have added phone lines to accommodate the growing demand for Internet access. However, as high-speed DSL and cable Internet access become more readily available, the demand for additional telephone lines may diminish, cutting into a lucrative source of revenue for local phone companies. Capital spending by telecommunications services companies has soared in recent years, although it was expected to level off in 2000 in response to higher interest rates and reduced earnings growth. Nevertheless, high levels of telecommunications equipment investment are expected to continue for the foreseeable future, as telecom service firms require additional equipment upgrades to accommodate increased network traffic and wireless applications (see Chart 2).
|
|
Cable TV Cable TV is another important component of the telecommunications services industry. According to Economy.com, "among the current technologies available, cable is viewed as the leading option for delivering video, telephony, entertainment, and computing services to households and businesses."2 Cable TV sales revenue has grown more than 19 percent a year since 1995. In spite of this stellar revenue growth, most cable companies are not earning a profit because of the high levels of capital investment required. 2 September 2000. Economy.com, Precis: Industry: Cable TV. Telecommunications Equipment The telecommunications equipment industry is growing rapidly, as telecom service providers rush to upgrade infrastructure to enhance their offerings of high-speed broadband services. Telecommunications service providers are not only upgrading fiber optic and cable line networks; they are rapidly upgrading antiquated circuit-switched networks to more efficient packet-switch networks. However, the growth in revenues and profits was expected to moderate in 2000 because of higher interest rates and slower growth in the domestic economy (see Chart 3).
Chart 3[D]
The wireless phone industry also has experienced problems since late 2000. The major mobile phone companies have missed earnings projections, casting doubt on the growth potential of the industry. Much is riding on the development of third-generation (3G) wireless technology, which is expected to allow wireless access to the Internet, transmission of video and other images, and videoconferencing-all from a handheld mobile phone. Although huge amounts of money are being invested to develop 3G technology, it is unclear what applications will generate the demand to make the investments profitable. Outlook The telecommunications industry has been badly battered in both equity and bond markets in the past several months. A spate of bad news has resulted in sharply lower stock prices and higher costs in debt markets. As a result, the availability of financing for some higher-risk firms is now questionable. Investors are concerned about the prospect of slowing wireless subscriber growth, continuing capital expenditures, intense competition, and the rapid rise in telecom debt3 (see Chart 4). 3 Solomon, Deborah, and Nicole Harris. October 18, 2000. "Talks on Merger By AT&T Wireless Face Investor Static." Wall Street Journal.
Chart 4 |
|
The long-term outlook for the telecommunications services industry is positive. The emergence of high-margin technologies and continued growth in wireless subscriber rates should enhance profitability in the future. Consumers and businesses are also expected to spend an increasing share of their incomes on telecom services. Nevertheless, strong competition, huge investments in equipment upgrades, and rapidly changing technology will force firms to be nimble and innovative. The long-term outlook for the telecommunications equipment industry is positive, as the demand for data, Internet, and wireless services continues to grow strongly. Nevertheless, individual firms in the industry face a highly competitive environment and rapidly changing technology. Cable TV's long-term outlook is also positive because of growing advertising sales and technological developments that should allow cable firms to offer a broader array of services. Still, the competitive environment is fierce. In addition to competing with a host of "traditional" telecommunications firms, cable firms must contend with satellite TV providers, which are partnering with major firms to offer sophisticated communications and entertainment services. Implications for Banks The most important characteristics of the telecom industry with respect to lending risks are its highly competitive environment and its pace of technological change. These characteristics suggest that the medium- to long-term outlook for a particular credit may not be well represented by current conditions. The success of telecom firms will be based on management's ability to adapt to change and compete with a fluid set of competitors. With both equity and bond markets turning against the telecommunications industry, cash-hungry telecom firms may have difficulty obtaining financing. This could pose a serious risk for banks with a significant exposure to telecom start-ups without a major partner or an investor sponsor. The high capital requirements and financial leverage of many telecommunications firms complicate these lending risks. Some of these firms are borrowing heavily to put into place an infrastructure to accommodate a demand for services that is yet to come on-stream, meaning that the payback on this investment may not occur for a number of years. Health CareIndustry trends such as declining hospital occupancy rates and rising outpatient visits to hospitals, intense competition, and the unexpected results of new Medicare policy combined to put the health care industry in difficult financial straits during the past few years. However, subsequent industry consolidation and streamlining and revised Medicare rules have helped to stabilize prospects for many health care providers. Recent Trends and Developments The health care industry has been suffering since the implementation of the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 (BBA), which cut Medicare payments much more than expected. However, two subsequent bills were passed to "give back" a portion of the Medicare payment cuts implemented in the BBA. The Balanced Budget Refinement Act of 1999 should restore some $16 billion of the cuts to health care facilities over five years.4 Also, the recently passed Benefits Improvement and Protection Act of 2000 (BIPA) will restore about $35 billion in benefits to the industry over the next five years. BIPA will provide the greatest benefit to hospitals, managed care plans, nursing homes, and home health agencies. 4 June 15, 2000. Healthcare: Facilities. Standard & Poor's Industry Surveys. The health care industry's financial situation has stabilized somewhat in the past year because of widespread consolidation of hospitals and other health care providers. This has helped the industry reach greater levels of efficiency as well as improved bargaining power in negotiations with managed care organizations. Notwithstanding these favorable developments, other trends continue to pose serious challenges to many firms. Higher labor costs, continued HMO penetration, breakthrough pharmaceutical therapies resulting in reduced demand for services, and increased outpatient volumes have buffeted many health care facilities (see Chart 5 and Chart 6). Chart 5 |
Chart 6[D]
Higher-Risk Sectors A better understanding of risks and trends in health care can be gained by discussing its specific sectors. We have segregated these sectors based on the results of an option-pricing model of firm default risk. These models estimate the probability that the market value of a firm's assets will fall below a level that would trigger default. Firms that have low stock prices, volatile stock prices, or high debt levels will tend to be flagged as having high default risk by such models. One such model that is readily available is Credit MonitorTM, which was developed by KMV LLC.5 We stratify health care sectors based on their median one-year default probability as estimated by expected default frequenciesTM (EDFsTM) generated by Credit MonitorTM. Sectors identified in this article as higher-risk sectors, therefore, are those with a relatively high percentage of firms with low stock prices, volatile stock prices, or high debt levels. Readers are cautioned that the risk profile of a specific company may be very different from the sector risk profiles described here. 5 Credit MonitorTM's Expected Default FrequencyTM (EDFTM) estimates the probability of default within one year. KMV LLC's proprietary calculation for EDFTM is based on (1) the current market value of the firm, (2) the structure of the firm's current obligations, and (3) the vulnerabiltiy of the firm to large changes in market value measured in terms of asset volatility. EDFsTM are one of many potential measures of industry risk, and their use in this article should not be construed as an endorsement by the FDIC or Credit MonitorTM. Health care industry subsectors have been grouped into three categories: higher risk, moderate risk, and lower risk, which refer to the degree of default risk relative to other subsectors in the industry. The estimated default risk across these subsectors varies substantially. The highest-risk health care sectors include Offices of Medical Doctors; Skilled Nursing Care Facilities; Home Health Care Services; Specialized Outpatient Facilities, NEC; and Health Services (see Chart 7). |
|
Offices of Medical Doctors are largely physicians' practice management firms. These firms acquire a practice of physicians based on a multiple of the practice's discounted cash flow. The multiple can be several times the practice's asset value at the time of purchase. However, these firms have had difficulty achieving profitability because of legal restrictions on referrals among affiliated groups of physicians, as well as the reluctance of physicians to submit their medical practice to the criteria of cost control.6 Total liabilities in this sector have grown rapidly over the past few years. 6 Gruehn, Charles. April 2000. Healthcare Industry Manual. Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta. Skilled Nursing Care Facilities' earnings have been hurt badly by the BBA. However, they stand to benefit from the Medicare "giveback" provided by the recently enacted BIPA, which seeks to rectify the deeper-than-expected cuts in funding resulting from the BBA. Skilled nursing care facilities' performance has also been adversely affected by (1) declining occupancy rates caused at least partly by increased competition from lower-acuity facilities such as assisted living facilities; (2) rising labor and legal costs; and (3) surging debt service costs. Many of these firms are experiencing severe financial stress. The stressed facilities have registered negative net income for the past year or so, as well as burgeoning debt levels. The high debt levels are the result of acquisitions of ancillary support services that in many cases are not generating adequate cash flow because of the BBA.7 Most of these firms have seen their interest coverage ratios decline sharply over the past few years. 7 Ibid. Home Health Care Services focus primarily on respiratory therapy programs and intravenous and infusion services. The industry is undergoing financial stress as a result of the Health Care Financing Administration's implementation of a prospective payment system that reduced reimbursements on respiratory therapy and infusion therapy. Specialty Outpatient Facilities, NEC are primarily engaged in outpatient care of a specialized nature, such as alcohol and drug treatment and birth control/family planning. They have permanent facilities and medical staff to provide diagnosis, treatment, or both for patients who are ambulatory and do not require inpatient care. Many of the firms in this sector have experienced a rising debt burden over the past few years, pushing default risk to higher levels. Health Services firms are engaged primarily in furnishing medical, surgical, and other health services. Firms listed in this broad category rather than more specific categories include companies providing dental services, laser eye correction, and physical and occupational therapy. Many publicly traded firms in this category have experienced sharply rising liabilities over the past three to four years. Moderate-Risk Sectors Moderate-risk health care sectors include medical laboratories, hospitals, and HMOs. Medical Laboratories provide professional analytic or diagnostic services to the medical profession or to the patient as prescribed by a physician. Companies with diverse financial performance and risk of default are included in this sector. A number of medical laboratories have registered deteriorating interest coverage ratios in the past year or two. Hospitals, as defined for these purposes, are specialty hospitals. They are primarily engaged in providing diagnostic services, treatment, and other hospital services for specialized categories of patients. Only eight publicly traded firms are listed in this category. They are involved in providing specialized hospital care such as rehabilitation, diabetes treatment, and drug and substance abuse treatment. Hospital and Medical Service Plans (HMOs) are primarily engaged in providing hospital, medical, and other health services to subscribers or members in accordance with prearranged agreements or service plans. Generally, these service plans provide benefits to subscribers or members in return for specified subscription charges. Also included in this industry are separate HMOs that provide medical insurance. After several years of intense competition among HMOs, which restricted premium-rate hikes when medical costs were rising sharply, HMOs began to pursue a more aggressive approach toward price increases. This new approach has improved the near- and intermediate-term outlook for this sector. Yet, the prospect of the passage of a Patients' Bill of Rights suggests that rising costs could be an issue for HMOs in the future. As an industry, HMOs are highly concentrated, with the top 10 HMOs accounting for nearly two-thirds of total HMO enrollment in the United States. 8 See Standard & Poor's. August 31, 2000. Industry Surveys--Healthcare: Managed Care. Lower-Risk Sectors The lowest-risk sectors in the health care industry include miscellaneous health and allied services, and general medical and surgical hospitals. Many of these firms have an estimated default risk that puts them in speculative credit risk categories in spite of the fact that they are considered lower risk compared with other health care sectors. Miscellaneous Health and Allied Services firms are involved in providing kidney or renal dialysis services and outpatient care of a specialized nature, such as alcohol and drug treatment and birth control/family planning. Some firms are engaged in providing health and allied services such as blood banks, blood donor stations, childbirth preparation classes, medical photography and art, and oxygen tent services. General Medical and Surgical Hospitals provide general medical and surgical diagnostic and treatment services, other hospital services, and continuing nursing services. They have an organized medical staff, inpatient beds, and equipment and facilities to provide complete health care. According to a study conducted by HCIA-Sachs and Ernst & Young, "The BBA created the greatest financial instability that hospitals have experienced since the creation of Medicare in 1965. Yet the most severe reductions have just begun to impact hospitals, and will continue to do so through 2002. The recently enacted Balanced Budget Refinement Act provides little sustained relief to the industry, and significant financial problems are likely to remain."9 The study also indicates that smaller hospitals (fewer than 100 beds) are in the "greatest financial jeopardy." The recent enactment of BIPA will help to stabilize the finances of hospitals over the next several years. However, other trends adversely affecting hospitals include as much as 40 percent estimated excess capacity, rising labor costs, a severe shortage of nurses, continued HMO penetration, breakthrough pharmaceutical therapies, and increased outpatient volumes (see Charts 5, 6, and 8). 9 HCIA-Sachs, LLC, and Ernst & Young, LLP. May 1, 2000. The Financial State of Hospitals: Post-BBA and Post-BBRA.
Chart 8[D]
Outlook The outlook for the health care industry has improved substantially in the past year. Industry consolidation and legislation to give back some of the Medicare cuts implemented in the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 have gone a long way to stabilize health care providers' financial prospects, particularly those of hospitals and nursing homes. The passage of a Patients' Bill of Rights in 2001 could also strengthen the hand of health care providers relative to HMOs. Such a bill could contain provisions that would weaken the position of managed care organizations to contain costs and negotiate with health service providers. Longer term, the demographic trends are positive, with the population aging and life expectancy increasing. The result should be a growing demand for health care services in the future. On the negative side, however, the current trends toward greater use of outpatient procedures and drug therapies will dampen the demand for inpatient hospital services. Implications for Banks The opportunities for financing health care firms will continue to grow into the future. Recent experience has shown that the financial performance of many health care providers is profoundly influenced by changes in Medicare policy. As Medicare expenditures grow to occupy a greater and greater place in the federal budget, Medicare policy will be scrutinized to an unprecedented degree, magnifying the importance of understanding the policy risk associated with health care lending. Powerful demographic trends should lead to the growth in demand for many health care services over the next 10 to 20 years. For example, demand for nursing homes and assisted living facilities will increase sharply as baby boomers reach old age. However, regional supply and demand for these services can get out of balance as providers add facilities to meet demand. Monitoring local demand and supply trends is an important part of assessing the credit risks in these loans. TextilesThe textile industry has been plagued by excess capacity, fierce competition from cheaper imports, and sagging textile prices. The result was a sharp drop in industry profits in 1999 and continued weakness in 2000. Recent Trends and Developments The textile industry is a mature industry that by a number of measures has been declining. Intense competition from low-cost imports has taken its toll on domestic textile businesses. Since 1995, textile imports have increased nearly 50 percent while exports have grown just under 10 percent. A strong dollar should help textile imports continue to outpace exports. As a result of industry consolidation and the movement of many operations offshore, textile employment has continued to fall steadily. Textile employment has dropped from 663,000 in 1995 to an estimated 544,000 in 2000.10 10 Economy.com. November 2000. Apparel and Textiles, Precis Industry. Closely linked to all these trends, labor productivity in the textile industry is low relative to the average for other manufacturing industries because of low output prices and a heavier reliance on labor in the production process. The Department of Commerce reports that the industry's profit as a percentage of sales declined from 3.2 percent in 1998 to just 1.3 percent in 1999 (see Chart 9).11 Also, drought in the South has had an adverse effect on textile manufacturing firms, as these firms use a large amount of water in bleaching and dyeing fabric.12 11 Office of Textiles and Apparel, U.S. Dept. of Commerce. September 6, 2000. Current Situation in the U.S. Textile, Apparel, and Manmade Fiber Industries. 12 Kilman, Scott, and Amy Merrick. July 25, 2000. "Drought in the South Crimps Economy in Region." Wall Street Journal.
Chart 9[D]
Chart 10 |
|
Because of improving global demand and plant closings in the United States, many analysts believe textile prices have now reached a low point. Indeed, data for 2000 show a slight increase and some firming of prices in the first three quarters of the year (see Chart 10). Nevertheless, the profit picture seems to have weakened further in 2000 because of an increase in nonoperating expenses. Publicly traded firms in the textile industry can be separated into six major categories: knitting mills, textile mill products, broadwoven fabric mills-cotton, broadwoven fabric mills-manmade fiber/silk, carpets/rugs, and miscellaneous fabricated textile products. The default risk characteristics of these sectors vary significantly as measured by the median EDFTM. Higher-Risk Sectors The higher-risk sectors include knitting mills, Broadwoven Fabric Mills-Cotton, and Textile Mill Products (see Chart 11).
|
|
Knitting Mills are engaged in knitting, dyeing, and finishing hosiery, stockings, outerwear, underwear, and other products from yarn or knitted fabrics. Two public firms in this industry accounted for 66 percent of the sector's 1999 sales. Three out of eight firms in this sector reported net losses and six out of eight reported declining sales in 1999. The trends are similar in 2000 based on incomplete available data. Broadwoven Fabric Mills-Cotton are engaged primarily in weaving fabrics more than 12 inches in width, wholly or chiefly by weight of cotton. One dominant firm accounted for nearly 38 percent of the sales of all publicly traded firms in this sector in 1999. The performance of firms in this sector was mixed in 1999. Six out of nine of these firms recorded negative net income in 1999. Two companies reported a sizable increase in 1999 net income. Incomplete 2000 results suggest that six firms are in the black, leaving just three with negative net income. Textile Mill Products is a broad category that includes establishments engaged in performing any of the following operations: (1) preparation of fiber and subsequent manufacturing of yarn, thread, braids, twine, and cordage; (2) manufacturing broadwoven fabrics, narrow woven fabrics, knit fabrics, and carpets and rugs from yarn; (3) dyeing and finishing fiber, yarn, fabrics, and knit apparel; (4) coating, waterproofing, or otherwise treating fabrics; (5) the integrated manufacture of knit apparel and other finished articles from yarn; and (6) the manufacture of felt goods, lace goods, nonwoven fabrics, and miscellaneous textiles. Two firms dominate this sector. Together, they accounted for over 60 percent of the sector's sales in 1999 (considering publicly traded firms only). Net income for both firms was off sharply in 1999. Still, some companies registered net income gains in 1999, building on several years of growth in net earnings. Although the 2000 data are incomplete, most firms in this sector have reported weak earnings. Indeed, several firms have reported more quarters of negative than positive net income. Moderate-Risk Sectors The moderate default risk sectors include Miscellaneous Fabricated Textile Products and Broadwoven Fabric Mills-Manmade Fiber/Silk. Miscellaneous Fabricated Textile Products includes businesses primarily involved in manufacturing curtains and draperies, house furnishings, textile bags, and canvas and related products; performing pleating, decorative and novelty stitching, and tucking for the trade; manufacturing automotive trimmings, apparel findings, and related products; Schiffli machine embroideries; and manufacturing fabricated textile products, not elsewhere classified. Net income for three out of the five publicly traded firms in this sector was negative in 1999. Two of those firms have experienced losses for at least two years' running. Most of these firms reported negative net income through the first two or three quarters of 2000. The three largest firms' total debt has grown considerably over the past few years. The increase is related primarily to financing acquisitions. Broadwoven Fabric Mills-Manmade Fiber/Silk are engaged in weaving fabrics more than 12 inches in width using primarily silk and manmade fibers, including glass. Net income for each of the six publicly traded firms in this category was down in 1999-in most cases down sharply. Earnings for most of these firms appear to have continued to deteriorate in 2000. Interest coverage ratios for several firms were down in 1999 and 2000 because of lower income, higher liabilities in some cases, and higher interest rates. Lower-Risk Sector Manufacturers of carpets and rugs represent the only lower-risk sector in the textile industry. Carpets/Rugs businesses are involved in manufacturing woven, tufted, and other carpets and rugs. This sector, as a group, experienced strong income growth in 1999. Only one out of six publicly traded firms failed to make a profit in 1999, and several firms reported sizable profit increases. Available 2000 data suggest that each of these firms will have generated positive earnings. Two firms dominate the carpet and rug sector, accounting for about 65 percent of 1999 sales for the group. Carpet and rug manufacturing is capital and research intensive, which gives the U.S.-based firms a comparative advantage over overseas companies, which do not have the same level of access to capital markets and an educated workforce. Outlook Some positive factors could temper the adversity being experienced by the U.S. textile industry. Low fiber costs and an improved trade situation with Asia should strengthen the textile industry in the future. Labor productivity has been rising slowly, as firms continue to invest in labor-saving computer technology and equipment. The industry is pursuing various strategies to remain competitive, including consolidations and mergers and setting up operations in Mexico.13 Nevertheless, the current slowdown in the U.S. economy and the increased risk of an actual recession has posed challenges for the textile industry. 13 Reichard, Robert. January 2000. "New Year Offers Problems and Opportunities," Textile World. Another concern for U.S. producers is trade liberalization and its effect on textile imports. The normalization of trade relations with China and the elimination of import quotas by 2005 according to the World Trade Organization (WTO) Agreement on Textiles and Clothing could lead to even greater imports. Implications for Banks Banks lending to textile firms face an array of risks emanating from the economic environment in which these firms operate. These risks include the ebb and flow of demand associated with the business cycle of the U.S. and world economies; the exchange rate of the U.S. dollar, which affects the competitiveness of domestically produced textile products; and the prices of both inputs and textile products. U.S. trade policy will also have a profound impact on the competitive environment in which domestic textile firms operate. Banks need to monitor these developments carefully. Concentration risk can be a significant issue for some banks. Textile mill employment is highly concentrated geographically. About 72 percent of all textile mill jobs are located in five southeastern states (North Carolina, Georgia, South Carolina, Alabama, and Virginia). Almost 29 percent of these jobs are in North Carolina alone. Another 18 percent are in Georgia. Even within these states, textile employment can be regionally concentrated, introducing concentration risk to banks with significant exposures to local textile firms. This risk is measured in terms of not only the volume of textile loans in the portfolio but also the spillover effects that plant layoffs can have in the community.14 14 See "Regional Economy," Atlanta Regional Outlook, second quarter 1998. In an increasingly global market, credit risk in textiles will depend on decisions about production processes and intercompany linkages. For example, capital-intensive domestic producers may be in a better position to compete with offshore firms with greater access to cheap labor resources. Some textile firms may be able to enhance profitability and control risk by entering into partnerships with domestic and overseas organizations. Stephen Gabriel, Financial Economist
Regional Outlook Information Return to National Edition main page Return to Regional Outlook main page |
| Last Updated 03/23/2001 | insurance-research@fdic.gov |
| Home Contact Us Search Help SiteMap Forms Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) Service Center Website Policies USA.gov |
| FDIC Office of Inspector General |